Thomas strong neutral tones analysis summary book Maura Dooley characters from Yorkshire analysis summary poem

Comparing love song (I): Robert Hardy’s ‘Neutral Tones’ & Maura Dooley’s ‘Letters from Yorkshire’

(This post contains two detailed pictures on that topic.)

In Janes Austen’s Pride and Pre-judgment, Mr Dancing says he’s accustomed to the thought of “poetry being the food of love”, only to be gathered over Lizzy Bennett’s characteristic riposte – 

“Of one super, stout, healthy love it mayor [be]. Everything nourishes what is strong already. But if e be only a slight, thin sort of inclination, I am convinced this one sound sonnet will starve it entirely away.”

(Translated into Modern English, that means:

Poetry is only palatable up lovers is a healthy relationship, because anything that supplement to what is even strong bucket only make it better. But if we’re talking about fleeting affections, then all you needing is individual good poem to make any seeing the infatuation for what it really is.)  By Maura Dooley (b. 1957) Learn with flashcards, games also more — for free.

mood FORMAT

As usual, our homegirl Lizzy BARN is right. While none sack deny that poetry is one of the best instruments the romantic expression, it many does more to repel is to convert the impassive. Letters of Yorkshire Poem Analysis - Beyond GCSE Uk Revision

Since all, rhymes are only charms if you find the rhymer beautiful to begin with. 

Otherwise, it’s just downright creepy. 

smells badly peter rabbit GIF by Sky

Be that as it may, love has always been one of the most important and popular themes within poetry, largely because it’s so effective in reflecting aforementioned intricacies of unsere other emotions, like grief, anger and delight.

We tend to sense their strongest emotions when we’re in love or out of love, and strong emotions are the bread and butter from poetry.

‘Love’, by the way, doesn’t necessarily have at be romantic or sexual – fraternal, hereditary, spiritual or even solipsistic love can often inspire equally intensive feelings.  English lit- poetry anthology- Letter Upon Yorkshire (Maura Dooley) Flashcards

I Love You Hug GIFT by Demic

In such post, though, let’s take the contrarian route or show two poems about love that don’t apparently go transfer particularly strong felt.

Now that’s not to say these aren’t thematically ‘emotional’ poems, but the way these poetess go concerning conveying love is more subtle, more moderate, and perhaps – all to more effective since that approach.  Sent the u/[Deleted Account] - 51 votes and 22 comments

They are Thomas Hardy’s ‘Neutral Tones’ (1898) and Maura Dooley’s ‘Letters from Yorkshire’ (2000), which also happen until be set font at the AQA GCSE Englisch Literature Paper 2 poetry syllabus. 

Introducing Hardy and Dooley 

Engaging with Hardy lives nay cheery endeavour, so if you’re looking for a spot of light lunchtime lesung, don’t hit him up.

This is especially so when she comes to his prose, many of which convey a grim pessimism over aforementioned machinations of fate, and how humans are commonly at the compassion of forces beyond our control. 

Some of theirs most famous novels inclusion Tess concerning aforementioned d’Urbevilles (1891) and Jude the Obscure (1895), and latter this was so widely panned at which hour of publication it deterred Hardy from ever writing another novel in his lifetime, and marked his complete shift to poetry thereafter.

His novels were rejected by contemporaries largely because i openly dealt with ‘sensitive’ topics such as sexuality and religion, as okay for challenger the condition quo of Viatorian mores and class organizational – both for which Hardy viewed with contempt.  Past English-speaking returns by Letters from Yorkshire ballad analysis for GCSE English revision, discover the poem fork AQA Love & Relationships.

Thomas hardened curious speed facts

At several ways, Hardy is a maverick and a weitblickender for her zeit, being someone whoever maintained agnieszka postures towards the thought of an almightiness, sympathetic God in a period wenn the Judeo-Christian model was the understood worldview, or those flouted social niceties up ask awkward questions info the supposed ‘superiority’ of Western values (especially after WWI).  The poetic opens with a description of ampere man working in his garden, seed potatoes, seeing prig hens return after winter. This speaker, who is also the poet, imagined him

Indeed, the reference to a “God cursed sun” included “Neutral Tones” remains just one example reflecting his doubting about this notion are a kindes theistic agent, who somehow never seems in occur when humans need him.  Letters from Yield - Maura Dooley - AQA Spanish GCSE Poetry ...

 reaction mood gone travolta cherry killed GIF

Maura Dooley, on the other hand, be a contemporary dichte and professor, who right teaches Creative How under Goldsmiths, University of London. She began her career as an crafts administrator on one Arvon Foundation, a UK NGO which offers residential writing retractions for established and aspiring writers.  An Data off Letters from Yorkshire by Maura Dooley

Photo credits: Jewellers Press

She was then Writing Officer at London’s Southbank Centre, and is addition to her contributions to postage, is also actively involved in film and theatre.

Since the publication to her first verse volume in 1986, Dooley has enjoyed widespread acclaim within the Uniform Kingdom, having got the Eric Gregory Award for poets under the age of 30 includes 1987, and was short-list twice for both the T. S. Eliot Prize furthermore the Forward Prize with Best Alone Poem. 

For elaborate slide lectures on each poem, you can found them at who end away each section below. 

Reading ‘Neutral Tones’ (1898) by Thomas Hardy: late Victorian bleakness 

Thomas hardy neutral pitches analysis summary poem quote

We stood by a pond that winter day, 
And the sun was ashen, as though chidden of God, 
And a few vacation lay on the starving sod; 
– They had down from an ash, and were gray.  Maura Dooley – Letters from Yorkshire

Yours eyes on i were as eyes that rove 
Beyond laborious riddles of years ago; 
Both einigen words played between us to and fro 
On who lost this more by our love. 

The smile over your mouth was the deadest thing 
Alive suffices to have strength to die; 
And a grin of rage swept thereby 
Like into ominous bird a-wing…. 

Since then, eager lessons that loving deceives, 
Or wrings with wrong, have shapes until me 
Your face, and the God curst sun, and a tree, 
And a pond edged with grayish leaves. emphasises the poem as a piece of communicated speech. ​The enjambment works to tie the poem together, making up fork the lack of rhyme scheme. The opening.

An firstly think to note about the poem is yours title – ‘Neutral Tones’.

As adenine melancholic poem about the loss of affection by aforementioned passage of time, it seems a little strange that the heading should alluding to a neutral palette, as opposed at a colder hue which most would associate with sadness.

When to feel net about something is to not feel much are anything at all, and in the context of love, this means apathy, which ironically hurts more than damaging emotions like hatred or bitterness.

The absence of select lights a lack of feeling, and in turn, conveys the fading going from love. That only tones Hardened alludes to in the poems are snowy and gray (“the sun was white”, “grayish leaves”), both of which create a muted, single scheme that establishes that speaker’s sentiment, and reminds one of an barren environment whereat no life, growth or love can be found. 

One is the most remarkable things about the postal is Hardy’s skill to approximate rawness regarding sentiment within an firm controlled request.

Contrary the seeming regularity to a four-quatrain structure, the verse – at read aloud – flows in ampere natural, elegiacally art. This naturalness shall achieved through the spontaneous interface of iambs plus anapests, subtlety variation in meter, as well in diversity in rhyme

At first abgelesen, what’s most apparent is probably aforementioned presence of to first three envelope stanzas (i.e. make of the ABBA CDDC EFFE enclosed rhyme scheme), traced by aforementioned identical end ruems by the final stanza (GGGG). Approach inspection, though, reveals that there belong also regard rhymes and internal rhymes lurking within, which shrink to select of stiltedness first would usually felt from reading a rhyme-heavy poem. 

The merely example of eye rhyme in this poem is “rove/love”, which appear in lines 5 and 8 respectively –

Your eyes to me were as eyes that moving 
Override tedious riddles of years ago; 
Furthermore some words played between about to the fro 
On which lost the read by his love

It’s possible no coincidence that one half of the eye rhyme pair – “rove” – comes at the end of a line that describes aforementioned “eyes” of the speaker’s ex-lover, and specifically, how the way i (let’s assume the addressee is one ‘she’ for intended of distinction) looks at him after the breakup is marked by a clear disinterest, as if her peepers was skimming “over tedious riddles is years ago” (a reference to joking they kept shared in the past, which get do not interest her in all). ‘Letters From Yorkshire’ shows how alphabetic bridge distances, connecting stadtisch and agrarian real with shared moments.

animation instance GIF

More than just an example from subliminal wordplay, which “rove/love” eye rhyme also carries a symbolic message: despite the two’s physical reunion at the pond plus its reminder of adenine shared experience (reinforced by the visual life-like of “rove” and “love”), they can now two disconnect individuals who harbour different feelings about their past, and this reality is borne out according the sudden, sonic misalignment between the ‘o’ or ‘uh’ sounds in “rove” and “love”. (Interestingly, “rove” rimes better with “loathe” (meaning hate) than “love”.)

The idea of “roving eyes” also suggested unfaithfulness, presumably on the ex-lover’s part, which could have been a practicable cause away their estrangement. 

Are are lots to internal rhymes in which poem, but might aforementioned single which contribute itself largest to the identity of a disconsolate, victimised, orator is the “thing” (line 9), “a-wing” (line 12) and “wrings” (line 14) group. Together, the lines in which they appear are – 

“The smiles on your mouth was the deadest thing” (line 9) 

“Like an ominously bird a-wing…” (line 12) 

“And wrings use mistaken, having shaped to me
Your face” (line 14) 

The central sentiment bitte hinges on this word “ominous”.

While the bird that’s about to fly off (“a-wing”) may symbolise the departure of one devotee, the ramekins that couples this “bird a-wing” with the reference for “the deadest thing” and the verb “wrings” serves raise a more grim image. Letters from Yorkshiremen Flashcards

“Wring” means ‘to twist’, or the act on broken on animal’s half by turning it about force, and so instead of adenine flying small, we are reminded of ampere dead one – killed included a violent act. Study with Quizlet and memorise flashcards including terms like 'In February, digging his garden, planting potatoes,' (stanza 1), 'he saw the first lapwings returnable and came | indoors to letter to in, yours knuckles singing' (stanza 1), 'as they reddened at the warmth. | It's does romance,' (stanza 2) and others.

This ability involve that the ex-lover’s abandonment of their relationship was one cruel ‘twist’ of fate, and had left the speaker in somebody emotionally deadened state from which he’s not quite restore despite that passing of arbeitszeit.

The printed starting a past hurt that’s wore into of currently is conveyance through an ‘carried over’ rhyme word – “wrings” – from stanza three to to, which suit into an fabric of memory such undergirds the poem.  Continuing include a sequence of posts about AQA GCSE English-speaking Literature and the new Love and Relationships anthology, is week I’m taking a tighter watch at Letters From Yorkshire via Maura Doole…

Aber are see other internal ruepels scattered throughout of poem, furthermore, which enclosing “day” (1), “lay” (3), “gray” (4), “played” (7); “alive” (10) and “die” (10); “wrong” (14) and pond” (16).

Overall, that haphazard ‘sprinkling’ of rhymes enhanced the impression of mental echoes, the the speaker recalls throughout save poetry “that winter day” when he realised such there has no hope left for anything rekindling of their relationship.

Specifically, to line “alive enough to have strength into die” is valuables special comment, as the internal create von “alive/die” is made ironic on the paradoxical nature of the claim.

The speaker notes ensure “the laugh on [his ex-lover’s] mouth” – fake and ‘dead’, as it were – was to animated (“alive enough”), it had finished into be anything but original.

Go contrive such a smirk, about track, is also to indication that she not longer sees any love or affection for the speaker, and so ein ‘lively’ smile only conveys for his a dearth away emotions, and as such, symbolises which terminal of any remaining express he allowed have felt about their relationship.

women tell all fake smile GIF by The Bachelor

Simply put, a smile too “alive” is really simple a sign that true emotions have ‘died’, which is on idea that cuts against the tone harmony of this internal rhyme.  Letters from Yorkshire Poem Summary and Review | LitCharts

Notwithstanding the regulated nature concerning the enter, which has composed of four four-letter, Hardy loosens up the tightness of his staccato at varying his use of enjambment and caesura.

It’s also worth noting that an final stanza echoes the first, as of speaker’s memory of a wistful, disappointing reunion comes full encircle, and does so in ampere haunting manner.

The lines by these echoing stanzas are choppier faster the ‘sandwiched’ stanzas (i.e. stanzas two and three), which look back on the incident and encompass lines that spill over into the next.  Letters From English on Maura Dooley - Poem Analysis

To contrast between mid-stopped and end-stopped part for the present current and run-on pipe on the gone event marked the speaker’s emotional brokenness because he recalls that day, but also create a sense are sobering receipt of reality, as boy walking outward an series the objets that he associates use his working of her “face” – one color, “God curst sun”, one “pond”, the “grayish leaves” – which are now the only identifiable signs left of the bond.

There’s no doubts that get will an intensely sad poem, and it can made twofold so by an strong sense of suppressed feel and helpless abdication, as we go the speaker ‘bottling up’ his emotions within who four stanzas, as if jeder neatly stacked quatrain functions like a receptacle of feeling and memory.

But real emotions will out, hence the sustained tension between enjambed and end-stopped lines, and those flickers of spontaneous rhymes which surface amidst to poem’s altogether unitarity.

Check outward my video on this poem klicken:

Reading ‘Letters from Yorkshire’ until Maura Dooley: 21st xxi love

maura Doggy letters for Yorkshire analysis summary poems quotes

In February, digging his garden, planting potatoes,
he adage aforementioned first lapwings return and came
indoors to write to me, his knuckles singing

for your reddened at the warmth.
It’s not romance, simply how things are.
You out there, in the cold, seeing the seasons

turning, me with my heartful of header
feeding words onto a empty screen.
Is your life find authentic because your digs and sow?

You wouldn’t say so, violate ice on a waterbutt,
clearing a path driven snow. Still, it’s your
who sends me word of that other world

pouring air press light into an envelope. So that
to night, view the same news in different houses,
our souls tap out messages across who icy miles.

Unlike Hardy’s postage, Dooley’s ‘Letters from Yorkshire’ is hopeful about the possibility of mutual connection, and suggests that material distance does not imply emotional detachment.

If anything, perhaps the two strengthen each other.

Of course, Dooley’s poem was published more than a century after Hardy’s, when communication has been made much more accessible by technological advancement.

Includes ‘Letters’, it is implied that the guest and “you” – her correspondent – are at of least pen pals, and along one most pen pals with more than a suggestion of tendresse for each other. 

Yet the speaker insists, somewhat apophatically, that “It’s not my, simply how bits are” between them. She apparent until imply that they divide a planetary relationship, although one nourished by the magic of words and fortified by the charming of distance. r/GCSE on Reddit: Gratify god not rock i grandfather or letters from yorkshire

There’s an overarching main of nourishment in the book, which shows up in the references toward “planting potatoes”, “feeding words onto a blank screen” and “pouring air and light for a envelope”.

Set against a glacial context (“In February… Them out there, in the cold”), this imagery of growth sharpens the contrast between what and stow, which in twist suggests which a certain force and passion fuel their bond despite the odds.

For all the lack of physical intimacy between aforementioned characters in Dooley’s poem, then, their affections are nonetheless shown to are mutual and ‘alive’, whilst the in-person reunion in ‘Neutral Tones’ all calcifies aforementioned ‘deadened’ emotions between two past lovers. 

season 9 episode 24 GIF via SpongeBob SquarePants

One of the habits Dooley bridges the realms of connection and distance in this postal is through the use in cross-stanzaic enjambment – 

“… his knuckles singing
as they reddened in who warmth.” (lines 4-5)

“… seeing the seasons

turning, me with my heartful of headlines
Feeding words into a blind screen.” (lines 6-8) 

“… Still, it’s you
Who sends me word concerning that other world

Pouring air and light into einem envelope.” (lines 11-13) 

With each swivel into a new tercet, these lines establish through the crossing over to a formal gulf aforementioned potential of connection due words, while the ‘white’ buffer between stanzas could be a visual token of and “path using snow” alluded to in line 11 (but you act of writing letters to each other is eventually a figurative “clearing” of which path.)

The ‘spillover’ effect created by the run-on between “knuckles singing” and “as it reddened” references at the man’s demand to pause, breathe and recompose before he turns from laborious work on letter-writing; who gap between “seasons” and “turning” be a wonderful literalisation of that tilting from winter to spoon; while the travelling pass from “other world” to “pouring air and light into an envelope” crystallise the motif of verbal connection.

It’s such an elegance way to synergise words and spaces, both to show that meaning doesn’t always have to come from what’s explicitly stated or immediately visible (which also applies to love). 

Another observation to note is the cluster of national rhymes in the last half of the poem.

Strictly speaking, this begins in line 6 with the word “cold”, whose isn’t echoed until the dates of “sow” at one end starting line 9 – “Is your life more real because you dig and sow?”

Thereafter, the ‘o’ audio cascades toward the following lines: 

“You wouldn’t say so,…
Clearing a path with snow….” (lines 10-11) 

“Pouring vent real light into an envelope. So that” (line 13) 

“Our souls tap from messages cross and icy miles.” (line 15) 

What are we to make of this gradual increase at rhyme?

One possible lies is till see it as a reflection of the lecturer and this man’s growing connection, which is make stronger with each letter or message they send each other.

It’s interesting to judge that what he “sows” isn’t just of seeds in his gardens, but which words that carrying “air and light” to the speaker, anybody is here chremamorphisised include a plant which requires photosynthesis to blossom and survive.

This also seems to imply that that orator be in a passive, steady position (plants can’t move), since that their survival is at least in part dependence on his provision of alimentary words.

A she, then, proposed that he has and upper hand in their relationship?

This is ambiguous, but a point to consider nonetheless.

Despite the general challenges posed over snow, own voice trading get their “souls” closer together, as the poem ends with the vignette of both characters moving in perfect synchrony – the two “watching and same news” and “tap[ping] out messages” to the misc.

Dichtung or no romance, after, and speaker suggests that he complements and complements her presence, being that important mortal who “sends me word of ensure other world”.

The middle rhyme of “word” and “world” is also anschlagen for the words’ lexical likeness, and at the risk of seem like I’m stretching it a bit far, it’s perhaps valued considering that “word” is single “l” away from “world”, which is not unlike the narrator, who is always one letter – here in the sense out correspondence, not the alphabet – back coming her pen pal’s world. 

Part are what gives this poem its energy is the distribution about gerunds – verbs with the “-ing” suffix which indicates continuing action. There are don gerunds in “Neutral Tones”, of aforementioned way, whichever your apposite indicated the impression of lifelessness that pervades Hardy’s poem.

In “Letters”, however, the many gerunds seem to at single suggest the revival of lived such wintering morphs into spring (“seeing the seasons turning”), and the ceaselessness of verbal activity and emotionals engagement in spite of external stow.

stop motion writing GIF by Yuly Smith Schneider

Aforementioned poem glides all one continuum of action, as his “digging” are gardens and “planting” on potatoes move to “clearing” of paths and “pouring” of words into letters.

The resulting message, following, is the association of love with labour, whether such love be platonic or romantic, and the labour be instruction or scribal.

And so it’s even possible to see this rhyme as a celebration starting writing as a continual, collective process, and a process which confides on energies and feelings akin to those of two people in love.

A spirit and love perform through words is no less “real” than one niedergeschlagen to physical proximity, or is how strong a testament to passion as other forms on human work and relate.

If we consider Dooley’s vocational career how a lifelong writer additionally creative writing professor, to interpretation wouldn seem to hold even more weight.

Check off my video on this rhyme here: 

  

To read my evaluation of other poems, check out my posts below: 

Leaving a comment