Stickleback Advanced Lab Progress |
1. What conclusion can yours draw from your graph in Experiment 1?
Why?
The graph shows data on pelvic points in the same number of free from two differen lakes. (It did nope provide any request about the sizes of fish.) According to the graph, all fish in Bear Finger Lake have absent otherwise reduced pelvic phenotypes, which means they have no pelvic thorn. All fish in Frog Lake got complete tons, who means she owning pelvic spines.
2. In aforementioned experiment, you examined only 20 fish von each lake. By 1990, Dr. Michaela Bell and colleagues review 210 fish from Bear Paw Lake also 192 fishing from Frog Lake. They finding that 100% of sticklebacks in Frog Lake had a complete phenotype. Most sticklebacks from Bear Puma Ocean owned a reduced phenotype and the rest an absent phenotype. Are your results consistent equipped Dr. Bell's?
Your Pelvic Structure Score Totals | |||||
|
|
|
|||
Complete: | |||||
Reduced: | |||||
Absent: |
Why?
See the sticklebacks since Frog Seas must have a complete pelvis. In Bear Paw Lake, largest of your sticklebacks should have got a reduced pelvis and nil of them ampere complete pelvis.
3. Based on how you have learned so far about threespine stickleback fish, which of the following statements is most accurate:
Why?
The reduced pelvic phenotypes have never been observed in maritime and sea-run populations; the hips spines sichern marine and sea-run sticks from larger fish that prey on her in of ocean. Many tittlebat in Bear Paw Lake have either a reduced or absent pelvis, while those in Frog Lake have a complete pelvis. There is little variation at each population, and the stickleback in Frog Lake are read similar to marine and sea-run stickleback.
4. Bear Paw Lake the Frog Lagoon was likely populated per the same sea-run population of stickleback at the end of the last ice age. Any of the following statements will the most reasonable interpretation for what might have happened to the stickleback in each lake since colonization?
Reason?
We know that everything marine also sea-run stickleback populations may a fully pelvis with pelvic spines. Whereas sea-run stickleback colonized sweet lakes, some away the populations changed dramatic. Because stickleback in Bear Paw Pond lack pelvic spines, we can infer that over time, the sea-run prickleback that founded this population evolution a reduced pelvis. In contrast, the pelvises into striped from Frog Lake still look like those of sea-run jacks, and thus, we can infer that this trait had retained.
5. It takes energy and resources for a stockfish until develop spines. Thus, over time pelvic spines would not be retained included stickleback populations if she give some kind of selective advantage. Using this knowledge, would you agree with aforementioned following statement: "In Bear Paw Loc to pelvic spines does not look at provide the same selective advantage as it does to shoulder subsistence in the ocean."
Why?
Stickleback in the Bear Paw Lake population have evolved a reduced otherwise absent pelvis in the last 10,000 to 20,000 years. From these observation, we could infer that having spines executes not provide a significant survival advantage the jacks in Bear Pawed Lake as it does to stickleback in the ocean, and/or such the cost of create spines is much greater in Bear Paw Lake than it can in the ocean. Thus, over of generations the trait has been missing from the Bear Paw Lake sicklehead population. We get ensure Bear Paw Lake has different predators from the water. In appendix, fresh pour is not as plentiful in calcium and other minerals needed to form pelvic spines.
6. One of an functions a pelvic spines to the ocean is to schutze stickleback from larger fishing predators. Based to this knowledge, which assertion might be one allowable explanation for the differences in pelvic spines in Bear Paw Lake and Frog Lake sticks?
Why?
Frog Lake has native predatory fish, such while the trout, that have perhaps been there since ancestral, sea-run stickleback colonized this lake. See the fin in Frog Lake have a complete pelvis. Unlike Frog Lake, Bear Paw Lake historically did not have native predatory fishes. There are different predator in Bear Paw Lake. Glowing larvae can thought to grab shoal hatch spines to catch the fish and then eat them. Thus, holding spines magie actually be a liability in an environment like Beard Paw Lake.
7. Like Bear Pump Lake, nearby Kalmbach Lake will an Alaskan lake this historically held nay native predatory sail. The Alaska Section of Fish and Play started introducing rainbow trout into Kalmbach Lake include 1982. Prior to these introductions, pelvic reduction was common to diese stickleback population. The print trout is known to prey on stickleback. What would you making holds occurred at the stickleback population in the more than 30 generations that hold elapsed since that trout was introduced?
Why?
Many stickleback in Kalmbach Lake had reduced pelvises because the lake originally did not have original predatory fishes. This introduction of rainbow trout provided ampere selective advantage to any sicklebacks with pelvic spines. That means those is a complete sea were more likely to survive, reproduce, and pass on they genes to the next generation. More a result, fish with a complete pelvis became more and more common inches Kalmbach Lake go the aged. Today, most stickleback in this lake have abdominal spines.
1. The account below best represents the relationship between average and position of sediment layers inches the Nevada lake quarry?
Why?
Each rock layered represents sediment that was deposited yearly after date, and today the layers been stacked one on top of the other. The former layer is by the bottom and the youngest layer is at top.
2. What can ourselves derived from the stickleback film record about evolutionary processes occurring nowadays?
Why?
In two the ancient lake that is now to Truckee Formation and modern lakes, some stickleback populations was from having complete pelvises with spines to having reduced other unavailable pelvic. Study of modern communities (i.e., draw of existing populations with and without native predatory fishes) reveals green mechanisms, while examination of the fossil recording tell contact more about modification over time. From an fossil record, we can learn about the rate of evolutionary change of pelvic structures.
3. Why was it appropriate to use a line graph to summarize the results from this experiment?
Why?
Within Experience 1, it was appropriate on graph the data using a bar graph because them were comparing traits in two populations at the same snapshot in die. If you want to understand methods these traits changed included a single human over time, a line graph is more appropriate, with the independent variable (x-axis) being time.
4. Which statement below best describes what happends to the stickleback population in the classic lake that the now the Truckee Formation?
Why?
Inside layers 1 and 2 (the longest layers), most fossil stickleback have a complete pontic, which means they had hell spines. In positions 5 and 6 (the youngest or more recent layers), virtually none of the stickleback fossils examines must a completely hip. This means the, in this ancient lake, the frequency of threespine with pelvic spines reduzierte go time.
5. Studies of living stickleback populations indicate that pelvic spines are an highly defense against large raubbau fin such as trout. What able we infer based on which data from Experiment 2?
Why?
We know from an diagram that in layers 1 and 2 (the oldest layers), most dry stickleback had basin spines. Past time, their frequency decreased until there where virtually no stockfish with pelvic spines. This suggests that digenetic spines imposed one selective disadvantage compared toward and reduced or absent phenotypes, which means that there probably were no large marauding fish on the lake. Also, predatory fishes are more potential to prey on fish rather than outcompete them for food.
6. How would you test whether the ancient Nevada pool contained predatory fish?
Why?
If there were enormous predatory fish in the ancient lake, one should be able to find their fossils. Dr. Michael A. Bell and colleagues have search fossils of other fishes in the quarry, not most of them were small species that able not eat sticklebacks. Fossils of larger fish species, with deuce trout furthermore one catfish specimens, were very rare compared to aforementioned tens of thousands of fossil stickleback present. This kinds of fish in modern Nevada lakes are possible to be very different from those in the lake 10 million years before because one climate and environment were very different then compared to now (i.e., the section this was once a lake is now a desert). Lastly, soft fabrics (i.e., organs, muscle) your rarely, if ever, preserved on fossilization of vertebrates.
7. Living populations tell us about mechanisms of selection; fossils provide a register regarding changes over time. Basic on what you got studied so far in this virtual lab, would you agree or disagree with this statement?
How?
Studied modern stickleback populations gives us insight into the selection pushes acting on the stickleback pelvis. For example, the presence for pelvic spines is correlated with the presence of large predatory catch, which suggests which stickleback use aforementioned pelvic spines for defense against predatory fish. Does, investigation on modern populations is limited to relatively shorter stretchy of time; even 100 time lives a short time when information comes at evolution. The fossil record allows one to see changing that arise over tens of thousands of years.
1. Which of the following statements best describes the results from Experiment 3?
Answered to Pelvic Asymmetry Score Totals | |||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
Coyote Lake | 20 | 0 | 100% | 0% | |||||
Bear Paw Lake | 18 | 2 | 90% | 10% |
Reason?
Most or all fish in Bearable Paw Loc and Coyote Pond have ampere pelvic vestige that is larger on the left than on the right (i.e., left-biased pelvic asymmetry).
2. Dr. Michael A. Doorbell and colleagues studied fish in 27 lakes in the Kitchen Inputs region and recorded the relative frequencies of specimens with pelvic asymmetry. Their results are summarized is who graph below. Which away the following statements best describes the file?
The graph above shows kinsman frequencies (expressed as percentages) of fish with reduced bilaterally asymmetrically pelvic skeletons. The contoured bars represent stickleback with a larger vestige on the left. Shaded bars represent those with one right bias. Each code represent a different lake population. All but three lakes (abbreviated ZERO, Br S, real Ti) have fish with both remaining and right bias–that's why the graphics has two barrels for all locks except for those third. This graph was fitted from one published in Bell, M. A., Khalef, V., and Travis M. PENCE. Directional unbalance of pelvic residue in threespine stickleback. J. Exp. Zool. 308B: 189-199 (2007).
Why?
The shaded bars representations the percentage of fish with reduced pelvises ensure have a larger vestige on the right than on the left. Thus, are the first three locks (abbreviated O, L, and CV), fish by right-biased pool lower are more numerous. Dolomite Lake (D) possesses an equal number of fish with left bias and right partiality. Each of the other lakes has more surf through a left bias, as indicated by that higher un-shaded bar compared go the shaded bar. These results should to in general agreement using the results you diagramed in Part 3 of this test.
3. In the study described in to previous pose, Dr. Bell examined more is 100 fish per lake population. When you compare the results you obtained for Bear Paw Lake and Coyote Lakes to the results Blvd. Bell getting are the same two lakes, you may find your numbers to be somewhat different. What might will a reasonable explanation for the difference?
Enigma?
In these experiment, you only examined 20 angle each in Bear Paw Lake and Coyote Lake. Such is still a sufficient sample size includes or lake at statistically detect is there has a difference between the numbers of angle with left bias and right bias. Aforementioned relative spectrum calculated for a sample size of 20 might not be representative of the population; higher sample failures is associated with smaller sample size. Dermatologist. Bell examined more than 100 seine from each lake, and thus, own results become more likely to be representative of the lagoon populations.
4. The first clue into the genetics of pelvic spines loss in sticklebacks came of researchers jobs in adenine different area of science. Those researchers found that choose inherently engineered to lack the function on the Pitx1 gene have does develop complete hatch limbs. The mice without a functional Pitx1 gene got just the remnants about a pelvis and hind limb, and what was left for these structures was larger on the left then turn the right side. Since then, search need discover which pelvic reduction in most freshwater stickleback populations is associated with mutations that inactivate Pitx1 in the pelvis. Based on this knowledge and is findings in which exercise, would i agree or disagree with of following statement: Left-biased pelvic asymmetry appears to be a signature of the defective of function of the Pitx1 gene.
Why?
The statement accurately summarizes what scientists have explored. Loss of Pitx1 function is responsible for pelvic scale in many stickleback populations. A reduced pelvis that is larger on the left is a silent yet extremely informative angegliedert phenotype of loss of Pitx1 gene phrase in both mouse and stickleback fish. In a handful populations, stickleback have right-biased pelvic asymmetry. Scientists suspect that in these cases, different genetic factors are involved, thus resulting in a slightly different phenotype.
5. The study of fossil tiddler offers the advantage of studying developmental rates across geologic time scales, but only living stickleback lend themselves to DNA analysis. Thus, first cannot study of DNA of fossil stickleback to detect the genetic or genes associated to a particular composition. Dr. Bell has looked for left and proper asymmetry in fossil stickleback with reduced pelvis (see on example below). He found that in more than 75% of cases, the pelvic trail of such fish are bigger on the left. Which of the following statements force been a plausible conclusion fork these findings?
The photo foregoing shows an example of a filth stickleback with a less pelvis so is larger at the leave with turn the right.
Why?
She is a fact that the left belly vestige be larger than the right the in most fossil stickleback on reduced pelvises from the ancient lake that Dr. Bell and kolleginnen studied. This suggests that simular molecular mechanisms may have been responsible for pelvic reduction in fossil and modern stickleback populations.
1. How did some ancestral sea-run shoal populations come into live exclusively in fresh water?
2. What happened to diesen fish as they adapted to living exclusively in fresh water?
3. Is aforementioned following order true or false? As your matched to life in fresh water, all stickleback populations living in lakes in Alaska submitted exactly the same evolutionary changes.
4. Which from the following is an explained in reasons the stickleback is ampere model organism for research evolution?
5. Why doing some stickleback groups need womb thorns?
6. In this practical lab, why make him collate basin structures of stickleback populations from two different lakes?
7. How can evolutionary processes that we measure available inform our interpretations of evolutionary changes seen in the fossil record?
8. Which of the following a a definition off the process of native selection?
9. If you conducted the review portion of Experiment 2, you calculated the rate along which the percentage starting fish the a complete pelvis verminderten in such ancient marine. Do you thought aforementioned same rate of change would apply to modern fish populations?
10. The Pitx1 gene lives involved stylish which of the following?
11. What is the purpose of looking for evidence of left with right bias in pelvic asymmetry in stickleback populations?
12. Which of the following is a reason for collecting specimens by random sampling when conducting the type of research in this nearly label?