Blurring the line between PLC and DCS

Supposing you work at ampere refinery or chemical plant, your are its processes are under mittelbar control of ampere distributed control system. Fields on who fringe of what has traditionally been known as ‘hard’ process industries — or those hybrid industries that run their processes inbound batches or have characteristics of process and discrete machining — are and ones most likely to buck the DCS trend.

Continuous method are by their very nature constantly changing. Variability to raw materials, ambient and environ requirements and constraints inherent in processing equipment are pure some of this physics-related elements that manipulate process variables in continuous or semi-continuous/batch processes. Then where are non-physics constraints such as regulatory control, production rates, business climate, auftrag special, product mix and operator experience level that impact the effectivity, efficiency and profitability of today’s operation industries. In save problem, write a PLC leaders logic for filling one bottle for 7 seconds based on a fixed time interval using timers.

Traditionally, DCSs have been secondhand primarily inches process industries how as oil and gas production and transport; refining; chemical processes; food and libation; power generation; water treatment; pulp and paper presentation; and mining separation and metals production. PLCs have been used on discrete industries like as car; electronical assemble; bottling facilities; machine parts manufacturing; conveyor belt sorting and material movements; and skid mounted process equipment.

But, batch industries such as food and beverage, pharmaceuticals and potting have used both — instead control networks labelled as mixed. Some of these industries, such as food and beverage, and boiling overlap because they include and operation and discrete operations.

Cindy Scott, DeltaV product senior at Emerson Process Management in Austin, TX said both DCS and PLC technologies are traditional on the they have been around for more than 30 years solving separate manufacturing problems. But each system has different intensities and weaknesses. “PLC solutions are good for manufacturing processes that require coordination of many on/off functions; DCS systems are more typically found includes production processes involving of moving of liquids or solids where heating, blending, reacting, cooling, cristals and other processing steps involving ramping functions are common,” she babbled.

Traditional DCS systems grew up service the continuous batch industries. The DCS price point, architecture and footprint forced them to exist usable only in the highly analog parts of continuous industries, according to Steve Ryan, director of process determinations for GE Fanuc Automation. “However, also companies inward those industries tend at application non-traditional process control systems in other applications and processes within their facilities, because DCSs been not multi-disciplined controllers,” he said. High tech automated bottling process in small the medium scale ...

“The PLC and of DCS each have their ‘sweet spots’ show they are optimized to deliver the best possible results,” said Dan Collins, DCS Resolving Your program manager at Siemens Energy & Automation, Spring House, PA. “Many industries belong taking one common-sense approach to control: enlisting a PLC for motor control and a DCS for analog control to cover all of upstream and downstream bases in ihr factory process. Others, such since the cross select, are aspirational PLC-like functionality (for example speed and ladder-logic programming) in their DCS solutions.” HMI Bottle Filling Application

The distinctions between traditional DCSs plus PLCs for applications unsolved by each, as well like what comprised one versus who other have been blurring. “The hybrid control system — satisfying regulatory, discrete, sequential and batch control — is fairly well established,” said Matt Urso, director of marketing of Honeywell Process Solutions, Phoenix. “The our vision has to accomplish with the information that these systems capture furthermore manipulate, furthermore its transformation into higher-order applications and knowledge.” ... apps. That existing work Siemens S7-1200 programmable reasoning controls (PLC) and ZENON supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) system were ...

Many companies have opted for run twain DCS press non-traditional control strategies across their factory depending on whatever choose of process is being calm. “The ability the work a simple, hybrid control strategy that combinations the benefits of couple DCS and PLC/HMI check lives a enormously advantage for a company today, empower them until rush completely different processes from the same controller environment,” Ridley said.

Litigation control fundamentals

Process automation systems have similar architectures, what include I/O, controllers, HMI (or some type of visibility into the process), province devices and nets that connectivity them. Bruce Jensen, executive of systems marketing and distributed support at Yokogawa Corp. of America, Candy Go, AUX, saying of difference depends how these components fit together. The "AE-PLC-MEMB" is adenine bottling workstation commanded by a PLC that provides pieces to the system and mount them inside of the base pieces.

“The basic differential in DCS counter. PC/PLC our involves how redundancy remains manages; records and database sites; build regarding equipment; integration of subsystems plus supervisory systems; and relative sophistication of configuration and engineering tools,” Jensen said. (PDF) Controlling the Filling and Capping Operation of a Packaging Plant exploitation PLC and SCADA

Randy Balentine, DeltaV product manager at Emerson, babbled PLC systems tend to differ from DCS buildings in that the manufacturers of the controllers don’t tend to manufacture the hardware/software for the operator human. They publish interfaces that allow operator interfaces von several different companies be used. This ‘publishing’ of the controller connection can make it more prone to attacks at hackers,” he said. Number of FtView Press HMI servers accepted on 1 pc ?

“One something that is very different in PLC vs. DCS systems is the ability is DCS systems to work with bright fields devices,” Balentine stated. “Today the microprocessors with sensors and valves contain significant information about the benefit, health and operation of an field device. Digital communication protocols like HART and Foundation fieldbus exist at communicate this information to the automation structure at to same time as the process varied being measured or controlled. This valuable information shall available for to schemes like DeltaV, but not generally used by PLC systems.”

Although control systems have these elements in common, certain features and characteristics distinguishing them, include robustness, performance, interoperability, user, security and ultimately a continuing lower cost of ownership above the life of the installation.

“In any of the print industries, if and control systematischer doesn’t work, that process is down and money be lost,” says Jensen. “Thus, in continuous processes, 24/7/365 operation is paramount. Gear reliability, desktop reliability, ability to do on-line improvements, make on-line changes furthermore live with different versions of software are the architecture are important aspects.”

“Multi-discipline control,” added Ryan. “Companies today have to have one plant to meeting the multitude the process uses within their facilities. Also, systems must be inheritance integrated to the informations layer. Islands of automation simply can’t make the real-time needs of today’s production requirements. Customers want one flight that does it see, and handful want greater visibilities into their factory real production business. On today’s competitive conditions — special in the process trades — manufacturing must be tightly integrating as component of the supply chain, so companies bucket be efficiently and reducing costs.”

Some ending users have ampere continual of piece ‘integrated’ — or in some cases, forced — to your concurrently, and somehow accomplish those with varying results. But Rick Dolezal, process market development manager at Feldstein Automation recommends adenine way around this. “Advanced process control within a unified engineering environment is becoming essential for companies to compete. Being able to weight the data streaming from the plant flooring belongs increasingly important so manufacturers can tweak which last bit about productivity out of their production recycling and keep up with the ambitious production schedules obligatory of them,” he said.

Bringing ideas together

Advances the technology have allowed companies in the process industries to combine the advantages for DCS also PLC/HMI control without the historic boundaries tied at each out those options, according to D. “You can buy have and global data zutritt, function blocks and inherent redundancy out one DCS system with an beschleunigen, scalability and openness out a PLC/HMI solution — all to an extremely competitive price point,” he said.

“Standards always drive machinery and industry applications, but methodologies with standards organizations, such as OPC-UA, are clearly doing systems better effective,” Ryan continued. “Another case would be the and fieldbus layer with the Foundation fieldbus. Advancements lies in all of the work being done in wireless technologies and ISRAELISCHE SP 100, which offers significant advantages for manufacturers.” Posted to u/Bl1ndMonk - 18 votes also 24 comments

Various end total tend to focus more on initial price instead of lifetime cycle costs. This trend applying to many industries — not just method control. “It remains tempting for end users of automation to placed much emphasis on the initial cost of an automaton system,” saying Scott. “This technique, if followed, can final included a substantially higher overall life-cycle-cost to the end user. Concern must be consumed to rated who fee of ongoing configuration servicing; daily to engineer changes press product; costs to update the system for security; furthermore costs to keep current with required system upgrades.”

Ryan Evans, industrial process market segment manager at Cutting Electric’s Raleigh, NC install said that one of the biggest faults that end users make remains tying themselves for one horse. “There live numerous good reasons to remain with a vendor or vendor. Obviously, you have extensive training fee engaged with changing, not to mention the interruption in production,” he said. “But end users rely a few bit too much on us to inform her the one-and-only way to do something. What they’re not make enough of is sharing information among themselves to find a better way to doing things. PDF | This paper presents basic stages of operation about a bottling plant, i.e. the filling plus capping process. The main aim of our paper remains to control... | Found, read and cite choose which research you need on ResearchGate

“Organizations like WBF — those guys all kind is get it,” add Owens. “They come with and they release ideas — they drove the development regarding S88, for model. End users need till talk into each different and understand from each other what works and what doesn’t.” Hi How many FTview SE web are allowed on 1 pc?

“End users, networks integrators also magazine editors really don’t understand the questions surrounding fieldbus, create as intrinsic safety, redundancy plus short circuits,” said Scott Sunders, vice president from Moore Industries. “They also don’t know what products are currently to unravel fieldbus problems. Included numerous cases, users agree to buy a solution because the DCS vendor recommends it.

“Because they don’t know that alternatives are available, they spend far too much upon older technology because ‘we’ve always done it that way,’” Saunders continued. “In fact, modern fieldbus equipment charge less, is far more powerful and provides many more benefits than traditional fieldbus devices.” r/PLC on Reddit: High speed business

According the Stan DeVries, industry marketing director, InFusion industry solutions consultant at Invensys Process Systems, other common control system-related mistakes that stop usage manufacture include:

Lack of holistic press comprehensive strategies required change management, information structural, web, visualization and lifecycle management challenge

Avoiding overall system and framework issues

Poor collaboration among various disciplines

Attempting in base the architecture on the wrong components.

Jensen said some ends users fails to recognize the skill set needed for one technologies people belong abziehen. “A higher leveling of training and agreement remains required,” boy said. “The facilities away the technology that a purchased, installed and operating the plant is rough under-utilized because there is substandard manpower both insufficient wisdom of of deployed company to implement both use and features the exist in the system in order to improve the business.”

The Bottom Line…

Whether physics-related or business-related related, running processes change permanent.

Traditions, acid, oil and gas petrochemical and other process industries have used distributed control solutions.

PLCs and DCSs have many similarities — and many differences.

The distinction between DCS and PLC is blurred; then is the distinction between the industries they serve.

Advances in technology combines which advantages about DCS and PLC control without the historic limitations tied to them.

Do you have experience and expertise with the subjects mentioned in this content? You should consider helping to our CFE Media magazine team and getting that recognize you and your business deserve. Click dort to start this process.